ANSI lacuna: interaction between SHARPSIGN-LEFT-PARENTHENSIS and backquote splice operator

[Evenson Not Org]

Faré notes in <​http://article.gmane.org/gmane.lisp.armedbear.devel/3101>:

What should this form read as?
`#5(1 , <at> `(2 3))

ECL, LispWorks and fare-quasiquote agree on #(1 2 3 2 3)
allegro, ccl, clisp, sbcl return the arguably conformant #(1 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3)
abcl, cmucl, gcl, xcl all return the arguably completely buggy #(1 2 3)

[Evenson Not Org]

Pascal notes

#5( anything ) should return a vector of dimension 5 in any case.

Furthermore,  

    "If the number of objects supplied before the closing ) is less than
     the unsigned decimal integer but greater than zero, the last object
     is used to fill all remaining elements of the  vector."

so they're all wrong, and expected result should be: #5(1 2 3 3 3)

Basically, 

            `#5(1 ,@`(2 3))

should take:

            `#(1 ,@`(2 3))

which all implementation agree that's read as:

            #(1 2 3)

and extends the last element to give:

            #5(1 2 3 3 3)


Now, since the reader macro is #\`, we should really apply #\` rules,
but the only rule for vectors is:

   * `#(x1 x2 x3 ... xn) may be interpreted to mean
     (apply #'vector `(x1 x2 x3 ... xn)).

so one could argue that there's no rule for `#n(…), and therefore it's
not a conforming form anyways.

If #n(…) is collapsed to #(…) then the abcl result is correct, as per
the above rule.

[Evenson Not Org]

Try for sbcl

`#6(1 ,@`(2 3 4))
==>
#(1 2 3 4 2 3 4 2 3 4 2 3 4 2 3 4)

is surely bad…

[Evenson Not Org]

Ticket retargeted after milestone closed

[Evenson Not Org]

Milestone renamed

[Evenson Not Org]

Ticket retargeted after milestone closed

[Evenson Not Org]

Ticket retargeted after milestone closed